Because of #Electron abandoning support for 32-bit PCs, this bug in #Wire is unlikely to be fixed, and I may have to give up on trying to use the Wire desktop client on my 32-bit laptop:
github.com/wireapp/wire-deskto

So having convinced a bunch of my family and friends to set up accounts on Wire and install it, I may have lost the main thing that made it attractive (a #FreeCode desktop client for 32-bit GNU/ Linux where voice calls work properly). At what point do I just give up on trying to be a #SoftwareFreedom purist, and buy a 2nd-hand MacBook for comms (and video editing, and ... and ... and ...) :(

@alexl see the 2-3 length discussions I've had here over the year about chat apps. TL;DR Wire is #copyleft #FreeCode on both client and server side, and has plans to support #federation between Wire servers. #Electron is a downside, but they are ok with community-created clients without Electron to connect to their server (unlike #Signal, don't know about #Telegram)

@strypey Telegram made a challenge and the best clients became the official ones: a Qt desktop client for Windows, Mac & Linux, two clients for Android, one for iOS, a web client and one specific for Mac, all Open Source, plus community clients including a CLI one. 200 mln of users, 15 bln of messages/day. E2E encrypted chats (optional) and calls.

@alexl @strypey ...but for some obscure reason, the server code is still closed source, even though they said they would open source it years ago. telegram.org/faq#q-why-not-ope

@stragu @strypey

Obscure reasons? telegram.org/faq#q-why-not-ope

Keeping Telegram fast and secure while switching to a federated architecture is a tech challenge. See Matrix, it's the state of the art of decentralized instant messaging and can't deal with Telegram's performance.

@alexl @stragu no, it isn't. #XMPP is much more advanced than #Matrix when it comes to server performance. But what's key is whether the company recognises that having servers they control at the centre of the entire service is a bad idea (#SinglePointOfFailure) or not. Wire does. Telegram hasn't even released their server code.

@strypey there is no point in releasing server-side code for an instant messaging platform if there isn't support for server federation. It's just a marketing thing, no benefit from security point of view

@alexl

Yeah, I've begun to think of that sort of architecture as being a vehicle for its developer's own "performative software freedom".

@strypey

@deejoe @alexl the benefit is it allows the whole system to be studied independently, including for security audits. You can stand up your own version of the server, check it for backdoors, and see whether messages are actually secure when you connect clients to it. It also gives the user community the freedom to run their own service for private use, and to fork if the original developer is exposed as a bad actor. So it's quite important.

@deejoe @alexl imagine how much work could have been saved in building the #fediverse if FB or the birdsite released their whole server stack under AGPL.

Follow

@strypey zero, there is no value in Facebook/Twitter codebase... Reddit was Open Source, but its federated version, Prismo, is being built from scratch

About Wire, I specified "instant messaging" because using your own server mean you and your contacts need to trust the same server managed by you or one of your contacts that maybe don't know each other... so at that point is better to trust a third-party company like Wire that has low interest in your conversations...

ยท Tusky ยท 1 ยท 1 ยท 0

@strypey ...and even if independent developers can audit the code and make it more secure you still need to trust Wire because you have no idea of what they are running on their servers. They could run a branch of the Open Source repo with optimized performance, with additional security holes... so the important part in e2eE systems is just clients being Open Source and secure

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon

Fast, secure and up-to-date instance, welcoming everyone around the world. Join us! ๐ŸŒ
Up since 04/04/2017. โœ…

Why should you sign up on mstdn.io?

This instance is not focused on any theme or subject, feel free to talk about whatever you want. Although the main language is english, we accept every single language and country.

We're connected to the whole ActivityPub fediverse and we do not block any foreign instance nor user.

We do have rules, but the goal is to have responsible users.

The instance uses a powerful server to ensure speed and stability, and it has good uptime. We follow state-of-the-art security practices.

Also, we have over 300 custom emojis to unleash your meming potential!


Looking for a Kpop themed instance? Try kpop.social