Follow

Want to find your way from A to B?

You should try:
maps.openrouteservice.org

I've used it a couple of times today, and it was great.

* Uses OpenStreetMap data
* Service provided by HeiGIT
* Doesn't spy on you
* Maps look great
* Effective routes
* Share with friends
* Add your own tracks
* Export to GPX plus others
* Elevation profile

You can also go to C, D, E and many more. 😉

@fitheach
Cool!

"What that? Who's there? Google? Is that you? I can just barely hear you now. Hello?"

Hmm. No search, no mail, no ads, no maps, no navigation. Guess poor old google is just down to sat images. Maybe...

gisgeography.com/free-satellit

"Say again goog. Say again..."

@gemlog
Well, they also have Android.

Do you use satellite images often?

@gemlog
I was just wondering. I've often looked at satellite images out of interest, but never had an actual use for them.

@fitheach

GIS normally uses stereo air photos, but sat imagery is also handy at times.

Here is some imagery I grabbed from ovi and drew our ski trails on for our local non-profit x-country ski club. Real version is in svg.

@gemlog
I use GIS on a weekly basis, usually for walking and cycling routes. I've never used satellite images. Scale isn't useful and they don't add much info (for me). Contour lines, and such like, are much more useful.

@fitheach I want to like this geocoder, but its formatting addresses really oddly (eg: 2318 E Cherry St, Seattle, WA, 98122, USA is formatted as East Cherry Street 2318, 98122, Central Area, Seattle, King County, Washington, United States) and I can't view the routing after entering in two addresses in Firefox for Android.

One other nit, is there any way to set the starting addess as your current GPS location?

@bikecurious
I've spent years (on and off) coding stuff for addresses and munging address databases, and it is always hard work. There are dozens of ways of formatting addresses.

The developers are keen to help, try asking them:
ask.openrouteservice.org/

@fitheach Cool stuff!
Looks like they need to update their OSM data though
That routing won't work... (ORS vs. OSM)

@brnrd
I think they made a new release today. It might be worth trying again.

If it still doesn't work try asking the developers:
ask.openrouteservice.org/

@fitheach Pretty cool service it seems. Thanks for sharing!

@fitheach

Thanks for this. Do you know of any similar service which also incorporates public transportation information?

@jaze
Sorry, no. This service has worked for me when I needed to travel by car or foot. Not had the requirement for public transport info.

You could try asking the folk at OpenStreetMap if they know.

@fitheach

Always curious why navigation software adds 20km to the trip? Is gas that cheap?

In time it saves 1 minute......

@WandelStock
Bugs happen.
The routing will be based on algorithms, they won't always be perfect.

Did this happen because you selected fastest rather shortest roue?

@fitheach

no, i just drove it that way because i am familiar with this part.

Google Maps, Here, TomTom are making the same mistake.

@fitheach Main disavantage: i have an error message when i try to calculate too long toll-free routes: «Code 2004: Request parameters exceed the server configuration limits. By dynamic weighting, the approximated distance of a route segment must not be greater than 300000.0 meters». As far as i know, it will be corrected this august.

@fitheach

Wow, really great!
I have use osm.org so far and always wondered if there wasn't a nicer interface - now here it is, thanks a lot!

(What would be even nicer: if public transport options (train, bus...) would also be integrated)

#osm
#openrouteservice

@el_joa
A tough one to crack, and you need resources to keep that information up to date. I bet Google spend a lot of money doing it.

@fitheach Hmm. Whenever I use OSM-based services, finding places gets harder immediately, even with very simple queries (see attached examples). Looking for a train station in Berlin, ORS either sends me in the US or literally somewhere in the district. Google on the other hand ... instantly gets me.

I'm not sure if I can contribute to the search results, but normal users will pretty much always fall back to the solutions that work instantly. :-/

@esureL
It is true (most) users will try a service and if they don't get immediate satisfaction will move off elsewhere. Human nature, I'm afraid.

OSM are always looking for people to help improve the data:
wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Ge

@fitheach the search failed pretty badly for me; try 'Manchester Piccadilly' - the search results are useless for it even though I can see it on the map; similarly Heaton park

@penguin42
WFM
I entered "piccadilly" and it was the first on the list. "Piccadilly, Manchester" also worked. Entering "Manchester, Piccadilly" didn't work. Funny, huh!

@fitheach @iona this is the site I was going to mention yesterday, but it doesn't work when you click on avoid highways (motorways) for a similar journey from the South to the North (apparently something is overloaded). This could be because both fast A-roads and motorways are being classed as "highways" by the algorithm.

Otherwise its a fairly decent route planning/mapping site..

@vfrmedia
Not a problem I have here, there is either a road or there isn't one. No motorways or dual carriageways.

You should let the team know about the issue, they may not be aware of it:
ask.openrouteservice.org/

@iona

@fitheach
Doesn't work well for me. Misidentifies my neighborhood and goes to the airport instead of the center of town when I specify the latter. Needs more work.

@zudn
Let the people know at Open Route Service, they are keen to resolve these kind of problems.

ask.openrouteservice.org/

@fitheach
I'm probably not techie enough evento describe the problem. :)

@zudn
What you described earlier is good enough for starters. If the devs need more info, I'm sure they will ask.

Give it a go.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon

The social network of the future: No ads, no corporate surveillance, ethical design, and decentralization! Own your data with Mastodon!